Ahhhhh. Now I see what's going on. You're talking about Blubrry statistics from two different shows.
In this case, you've got the property report episode 35 in both your Property Report and WordPress Tips and Tricks feeds. So, the stats being counted by both are different, based on each feed's audience. So, in order to get the total for the episode, you would want to add the two numbers from the two different listings together.